4. Feedback Orientation

Is my feedback preference supportive or corrective?

The Mindset(s)

Feedback orientation is a single bipolar dimension. It is not about how much feedback you give, but about which way you lean when you give it. Neither end is better; mentees need both, and the useful skill is knowing which one a moment calls for.

  • Corrective (the low end): feedback aimed at what needs fixing, the gap between the work and the standard.
    • Survey item: “I focus on mistakes to correct” (vs. “I focus on strengths to build on”).
  • Supportive (the high end): feedback aimed at affirming and encouraging, building on what is already working.
    • Survey item: “My instinct is to affirm and encourage” (vs. “My instinct is to close the gap to the standard”).

Polarity: Corrective ↔︎ Supportive.

Measure: Feedback Orientation, bipolar (author-created for this course). Three semantic-differential items rated from −3 to +3, where −3 = fully corrective and +3 = fully supportive. Your score is the mean of the three items, so 0 is balanced, below 0 leans corrective, and above 0 leans supportive.

Find Your Score

Use your password to find your score(s).

4. Feedback Orientation: your bipolar score (−3 = corrective … +3 = supportive)
Password Feedback orientation Feedback orientation (%) Lean
AARYA0510 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
ABBYS4444 2.00 89% (high) Supportive-leaning
APPLE4293 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
ARIGA0622 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
ARTEM1225 -0.67 3% (low) Corrective-leaning
ASOBI3022 -0.33 9% (low) Balanced
AVATG0607 1.33 72% (high) Supportive-leaning
Aster2306 0.33 27% (low) Balanced
BEARS1223 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
BINGS1234 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
BKNYC1616 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
BREES2018 0.33 27% (low) Balanced
BREIT3219 2.00 89% (high) Supportive-leaning
CAKES2713 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
CALLA1223 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
CCHEN1209 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
Corgi2016 -0.67 3% (low) Corrective-leaning
DMgie8191 1.33 72% (high) Supportive-leaning
FIRST2007 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
Flack7890 2.67 97% (high) Supportive-leaning
GALES9090 -2.00 0% (low) Corrective-leaning
GONZA2007 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
GREAT3333 2.00 89% (high) Supportive-leaning
HOLLY2550 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
Haeun1029 -0.33 9% (low) Balanced
Henry6789 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
JJNKV2226 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
KHANM7116 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
LARRY7733 2.67 97% (high) Supportive-leaning
LIMES1217 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
LOVES1206 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
LUNAS6002 2.00 89% (high) Supportive-leaning
MARKO0706 0.33 27% (low) Balanced
MOLLY1206 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
MOLLY8174 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
MRMLC8607 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
Mochi2906 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
Nevan2005 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
PETAL2141 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
Paris1258 1.67 80% (high) Supportive-leaning
Pools5678 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
RAYAS9214 -1.00 2% (low) Corrective-leaning
ROBIN0827 1.33 72% (high) Supportive-leaning
ROCKS0507 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
Roses0808 1.33 72% (high) Supportive-leaning
Rosie1007 1.67 80% (high) Supportive-leaning
SAMIA0267 1.33 72% (high) Supportive-leaning
SMILE1974 1.67 80% (high) Supportive-leaning
SPAHN2026 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
STEVY3792 -0.67 3% (low) Corrective-leaning
Steve1234 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
TACOS0510 3.00 100% (high) Supportive-leaning
TATER2560 0.00 12% (low) Balanced
TEACH3291 1.67 80% (high) Supportive-leaning
TEETH5157 -0.67 3% (low) Corrective-leaning
TILDA6348 2.00 89% (high) Supportive-leaning
Trees4311 0.33 27% (low) Balanced
VIBES1439 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
VRXAZ1127 1.67 80% (high) Supportive-leaning
YGITJ2954 1.00 56% (mid) Supportive-leaning
YonaG2026 0.33 27% (low) Balanced
ashes2007 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
buckl2105 0.33 27% (low) Balanced
press6028 0.67 36% (mid) Supportive-leaning
valve8250 1.67 80% (high) Supportive-leaning

Locate Your Score

Locate your score(s) relative to other peer mentors!

ImportantAbout this measure

No validated self-report scale exists for this bipolar dimension, so these three items were written for this course. They are grounded in the supportive/corrective feedback distinction but are not a published instrument. Pilot and check reliability before reporting results anywhere beyond this guide.

Reflect and Plan

WarningJournal
  • Score: How does reflecting on your score help you think about who you are as a mentor?
  • Behavior: To be the best mentor you can be, what is one new thing you will try to do this week for mentees and/or your team?
TipDuring Class

Make note of whether your feedback this week leans corrective or supportive, and whether that fit the moment.